As expected, on April 25, the People’s Court of Binh Thanh District (HCMC) will hear the first instance of the case of Nam An Cosmetic Hospital suing Vang Sen Company in the commercial business case “Dispute on brand promotion contract”. “.
In this case, the People’s Court of Binh Thanh District determined that Miss Grand Vietnam 2023 (Miss Hoa Binh) Le Hoang Phuong is the person with related rights and obligations; Doctor Chiem Quoc Thai (Director of Viet My Cosmetic Hospital) was the witness. Before the trial day, Mr. Chiem Quoc Thai submitted a request for absence.
Doctor Chiem Quoc Thai believes that he was involved in the scandal because beauty queens Nguyen Phuong Khanh and Le Hoang Phuong commented on his article on November 7, 2023, about his journey to be admitted to the Cosmetic Hospital. Viet My sponsors beauty.
Miss Le Hoang Phuong commented below Mr. Chiem Quoc Thai’s post
At the same time, thanks to cosmetic surgery, Nguyen Phuong Khanh and Le Hoang Phuong have become more beautiful and confident. Thanks to that, Nguyen Phuong Khanh won the title of Miss Earth 2018 and Le Hoang Phuong won the title of Miss Peace Vietnam 2023 and runner-up of Miss Peace World 2023.
Below Dr. Chiem Quoc Thai’s post, Miss Le Hoang Phuong commented: “Thank you, doctor, for helping me have perfect beauty and become more confident.”
In his application to the People’s Court of Binh Thanh District, Mr. Chiem Quoc Thai presented: Previously, Viet My Hospital sponsored free cosmetic surgery for Le Hoang Phuong. The hospital will have full rights to use Le Hoang Phuong’s image indefinitely for advertising.
After completing surgery on July 29, 2022, Le Hoang Phuong took photos at Viet My Hospital and the hospital posted them on Facebook to use for advertising.
“After that, Ms. Le Hoang Phuong competed in Miss Peace Vietnam 2023 and won the beauty prize. Although I had a commitment to agree on the right to use Le Hoang Phuong’s image for advertising indefinitely, to To ensure the rights of Golden Lotus Company, I contacted Ms. Pham Kim Dung (Director of Golden Lotus Company) to request to invite Hoang Phuong to be an ambassador for Viet My Hospital and Ms. Dung replied that according to the contract. At the same time, when Hoang Phuong is crowned Miss, she will naturally become the Brand Ambassador of Nam An Hospital,” Mr. Chiem Quoc Thai wrote in his application to the court.
According to Mr. Chiem Quoc Thai, due to the relationship with Golden Lotus Company and Miss Le Hoang Phuong personally, Viet My Hospital will not use Hoang Phuong’s image when this beauty queen becomes the brand ambassador for the Hospital. Nam An Aesthetics. Until the beauty queen’s contract with Nam An Cosmetic Hospital ends, Mr. Chiem Quoc Thai will continue to use Hoang Phuong’s image.
On November 7, 2023, Mr. Thai posted a status about Le Hoang Phuong’s journey of change and used a photo of Le Hoang Phuong taken at Viet My Hospital.
“The post absolutely does not use any images of Le Hoang Phuong since the beauty queen became an ambassador for Nam An Cosmetic Hospital. In addition, the content of the post on my personal Facebook is not only about I did cosmetic surgery for Le Hoang Phuong, but also for many other beauties. Thanks to cosmetic surgery, they have helped them become more beautiful and confident, so they have achieved high honors in the world beauty arena.
What I stated on Facebook is my personal opinion, so this post absolutely does not affect any rights to the contract between Golden Lotus Company, Le Hoang Phuong and Nam An Cosmetic Hospital”, Mr. Chiem Quoc Thai said.
The plaintiff in the lawsuit, Nam An Cosmetic Hospital, presented: On March 17, 2023, Nam An Cosmetic Hospital and Golden Lotus Company signed a brand promotion contract worth 10 billion VND. The content shows that Nam An Cosmetic Hospital, as the host of the Miss Grand Vietnam 2023 contest, has the right to “The crowned Miss will be the brand ambassador of Nam An Cosmetic Hospital for 2 years” .
Ms. Nguyen Thi Nhu Lan (CEO of Nam An Cosmetic Hospital) said that after Le Hoang Phuong was crowned Miss Grand Vietnam 2023, about 8 months later, on November 7, 2023, Nam An Cosmetic Hospital discovered Currently on Mr. Chiem Quoc Thai’s Facebook page (with green tick) there is a post tagged on Facebook with the name “Le Hoang Phuong”.
Below the post, Le Hoang Phuong commented: “Thank you doctor for helping me have perfect beauty and become more confident.”
Nam An Cosmetic Hospital believes that Miss Le Hoang Phuong’s comment is promoting the brand of another company operating in the same field as this hospital. Therefore, this behavior seriously violates the legitimate rights and interests of Nam An Cosmetic Hospital as recorded in the contract and appendix signed with Golden Lotus Company. Since then, Nam An Cosmetic Hospital sued to terminate the contract and request compensation.
In the trial scheduled to be heard on April 25, Ms. Nguyen Thi Nhu Lan authorized a lawyer to participate. Golden Lotus Company has 2 authorized representatives: Ms. Dao Thi Thu Phuong and Ho Thi Ly; Ms. Le Hoang Phuong also has 3 authorized representatives: Ms. Hoang Dong Thuy, Duong Thi Van Nga, Do Thi Nu.
