Revealing the “love line” between Quang Ninh Electrical Engineering and Vietnam Coal and Mineral Industries Group

As the Merchant said, Quang Ninh Electrical Engineering has a very good relationship with Vietnam Coal and Mineral Industry Group. During many years of establishment, the company has participated in up to 89 bidding packages of the Group. The total winning bid value also reached thousands of billions of VND.

Below, the Merchant would like to briefly record the bidding packages by year. First is year 2024. It can be said that 2024 promises to be a bumper year for Quang Ninh Electrical Engineering because even though only the first 3 months of the year have passed, this enterprise has won 3 bidding packages, including one from the Industrial Group. Coal – Minerals of Vietnam. In particular, this is the largest bidding package ever of Quang Ninh Electrical Engineering.

This package is called “Package No. 76: Supply, construction and installation of main well tower, auxiliary wells, main well shaft hoist house, auxiliary wells, main well shaft loading shaft system, auxiliary wells and control signal and communication equipment lost” of the branch of Vietnam Coal and Mineral Industry Group – Mao Khe Coal Company.

The total value of this bidding package is more than 865.8 billion VND, while the bidding price offered by Mao Khe Coal Company is 1,003 billion VND.

2023Quang Ninh Electrical Engineering won 7 bidding packages, of which up to 5 bidding packages were from member companies of Vietnam Coal – Mineral Industry Group such as: Duong Huy Coal, Uong Bi Coal, Vang Danh Coal

The total value of Quang Ninh Electrical Engineering won in 2023 at this Group is up to 56,852 billion VND and all are “one-way” matches.

Specifically, the bidding packages of Vietnam Coal and Mineral Industry Group include: “Tender package No. 04: Supply of coal seam temperature gauge, explosion-proof exploration drilling machine, anchor construction quality inspection machine, cement mortar press pump, two-drum explosion-proof winch, battery-proof electric boat explosion and passenger cars”.

This is a bidding package of the branch of Vietnam Coal and Mineral Industry Group – Duong Huy Coal Company – TKV. With this bidding package, Quang Ninh Electrical Engineering was the only unit participating in the bidding and won with a price of 6,594,600,000 VND, a difference of more than 70 million VND compared to the bidding package price.

The second package is “Package No. 11: Supply of blasting machines and auxiliary equipment in the mine” of the branch of Vietnam Coal and Mineral Industry Group – Uong Bi Coal Company – TKV.

With this bidding package, only the joint venture Tung Lam Import-Export Trading Joint Stock Company (main joint venture) and Quang Ninh Electrical Engineering participated in the bidding and won with a price of 3,515,700,000 VND, lower than 67 million VND. VND compared to the bidding package price.

The third package continues to be from Uong Bi Coal Company – TKV. This is “Package No. 18: Supply and installation of 2500kvA backup generator”. With this package, Quang Ninh Electrical Engineering did not have to compete with any other unit and won with a price close to the package price, with only a difference of 22 million VND, which is 14,542,000,000 VND.

The 4th package Quang Ninh Electrical Engineering won from Vietnam Coal and Mineral Industry Group is from Vang Danh Coal Joint Stock Company – Vinacomin. This is “Package No. 06: Oil-immersed transformer 15000 kVA, 3-phase oil-immersed transformer 75 kVA, Generator 2500 kVA, Generator 750 kVA, Soft starter cabinet 110-132 kW, Inverter cabinet 90-132 kW”.

Quang Ninh Electrical Engineering alone is bidding for this package. The bidding package price was 23,241,827,037 VND, while this company won with the price of 22,751,026,800 VND.

The 5th bidding package is also from Vang Danh Coal Joint Stock Company – Vinacomin. This package is called “Tender package No. 06: Electrical equipment of all kinds”. Quang Ninh Mechanical and Electrical Joint Stock Company and Toan Cau Construction Investment Trading Company Limited won this package for 9,450,109,900 VND.

2022, if in 2023, Quang Ninh Electrical Engineering also won bidding packages from businesses outside the Vietnam Coal and Mineral Industry Group, then in 2022 it will be the opposite. 100% of the bidding packages that Quang Ninh Electrical Engineering won belonged to companies of the Vietnam Coal and Mineral Industry Group, up to 17 bidding packages.

What is surprising is that most of Quang Ninh Electrical Engineering still compete “alone”, with a total winning bid value of more than 417 billion VND. Specifically, Ha Lam Coal Joint Stock Company – Vinacomin (4 bidding packages), Ha Long Coal Company – TKV (3 bidding packages), Duong Huy Coal Company – TKV (3 bidding packages), Vang Coal Joint Stock Company Danh – Vinacomin (2 bid packages), Mong Duong Coal Joint Stock Company – Vinacomin (1 bid package), Nui Beo Coal Joint Stock Company – Vinacomin (1 bid package), Mao Khe Coal Company – TKV (2 bid packages ), Thong Nhat Coal Company – TKV (1 bidding package) and Cao Ngan Thermal Power Company – TKV (1 bidding package).

Of the total 17 bidding packages that Quang Ninh Electrical Engineering won in 2022, the most special package is “Tender package No. 01: Supply and instructions for installation and operation of synchronous mechanized equipment system (light)”. This is a bidding package of the branch of Vietnam Coal and Mineral Industry Group – Duong Huy Coal Company – TKV.

The joint venture of New Technology Equipment Development Joint Stock Company and Quang Ninh Mechanical and Electrical Joint Stock Company was the only unit that participated in the bidding and won at the price of 110,689,796,160 VND, while the price of this bidding package was 110,891,266,000 VND. copper.

Besides, “Package 91: Supply and installation of Substations No. 6,7,8,10” of the branch of Vietnam Coal and Mineral Industry Group – Mao Khe Coal Company – TKV is also a bidding package that attracts many people’s attention. Because of this package, Quang Ninh Mechanical and Electrical Joint Stock Company won the bid for 17,625,268,960 VND, only 30 million VND different from the price offered by the investor.

Joint venture contractors Toan Cau Construction Investment Trading Co., Ltd. and Quang Ninh Mechanical and Electrical Joint Stock Company are the two units that won this contract.

2021, Quang Ninh Electrical Engineering won all 17 bidding packages, including 16 bidding packages belonging to member companies and joint stock companies of Vietnam Coal and Mineral Industry Group. The total value of these 16 packages is more than 190 billion VND.

Specifically, Ha Lam Coal Joint Stock Company – Vinacomin (2 bidding packages), Ha Long Coal Company – TKV (3 bidding packages), Duong Huy Coal Company – TKV (5 bidding packages), Vang Coal Joint Stock Company Danh – Vinacomin (3 bid packages), Mong Duong Coal Joint Stock Company – Vinacomin (1 bid package), Nui Beo Coal Joint Stock Company – Vinacomin (1 bid package), Mao Khe Coal Company – TKV (1 bid package ).

Notably, in some packages, the winning price is only a few million VND different from the package price and Quang Ninh Electrical Engineering is the only contractor participating in the bidding. Typical examples are the two bidding packages of the branch of Vietnam Coal and Mineral Industry Group – Ha Long Coal Company – TKV.

The first is “Tender Package No. TL09 2021: Power supply system and control and switching equipment”. With this package, the joint venture of 3 companies (Dong A Electrical Construction and Investment Joint Stock Company, Pressure Mechanical and Equipment Joint Stock Company – VVMI and Quang Ninh Electromechanical Joint Stock Company) won the winning price of 15,731 VND. 019,131 VND, a difference of just over 6 million VND compared to the bidding package price (15,737,143,335 VND).

Or “Tender package No. HL07 2021: Transportation equipment”. The joint venture (Quang Ninh Mechanical and Electrical Joint Stock Company and Uong Bi Mechanical and Electrical Joint Stock Company – Vinacomin) won at a price of 27,156,800,000 VND, a difference of more than 20 million VND compared to the package price.

If we talk about the packages with the greatest value in 2021, we must mention “Package No. 01: Supply and installation instructions for the sectional hydraulic frame rack system in 2021 Duong Huy Coal Company-TKV” of Duong Huy Coal Company-TKV. The joint venture of New Technology Equipment Development Joint Stock Company and Quang Ninh Electromechanical Joint Stock Company won the price of 56,598,069,000 VND.

Or the bidding package “15 2020 Mobile – Supply and installation of generators for Hoa Lac total stations and Hoang Hoa Tham total stations” of the Military Industry and Telecommunications Group. The joint venture of Mai Anh Trading and Investment Joint Stock Company and Quang Ninh Mechanical and Electrical Joint Stock Company won the price of 36,405,600,000 VND.

2020, Quang Ninh Electrical Engineering participated in 22 bidding packages and won 14 packages. In addition to the 4 bidding packages belonging to MobiFone Telecommunications Corporation and the Dynamic Urban Development Project Management Board of Thai Nguyen City, all the remaining 10 packages are from the Vietnam Coal and Mineral Industry Group. Male. The total winning price was more than 300 billion VND.

Notably, this year, instead of fighting alone like in previous years, Quang Ninh Electrical Engineering borrowed the strength of many other joint venture enterprises to win the bid. And this is also the first year that marked Quang Ninh Electrical Engineering losing bids, because in previous years, this enterprise always “hit every winner”.

It should be added that, 2020 is the year Circular 11/2019/TT-BKHDT on online bidding officially takes effect, bidding is tighter than before.

The businesses that Quang Ninh Electrical Engineering won the bid for include: Ha Lam Coal Joint Stock Company – Vinacomin (2 bid packages), Ha Long Coal Company – TKV (3 bid packages), Duong Huy Coal Company – TKV (2 bidding packages), Nui Beo Coal Joint Stock Company – Vinacomin (2 bidding packages), Mao Khe Coal Company – TKV (1 bidding package).

Among the 10 bidding packages above, Merchants pay the most attention to two bidding packages. The first is “Tender package No. 113: Construction, supply and installation of 35kV transmission line from Khe Cham 110kV substation to MBSCN+35 circuit 1 and circuit 2 and 35/6kV-2x18MVA transformer station No. 1 (MBSCN +35(+36) )); diesel power station No. 1 MB+35”.

This is a bidding package of the branch of Vietnam Coal – Mineral Industry Group – Ha Long Coal Company – TKV by a joint venture of 4 companies (of Quang Ninh Electrical Engineering won this bidding package for 89,738,982,470 VND.

It is worth mentioning that many contractors believe that this bidding package shows signs of violating the bidding form prescribed in Article 29 of Circular No. 11/2019/TT-BKHDT? Specifically, this bidding package must be bid online because the bidding package price is within the online bidding limit?

The second package is “Tender package No. 1: Supply of fly ash pumping equipment to prevent endogenous fires for self-igniting coal seams” of Ha Lam Vinacomin Coal Joint Stock Company. Quang Ninh Electrical Engineering won with the price of 13,493,260,000 VND, only 7 million VND difference compared to the bidding package price.

2019, Quang Ninh Electrical Engineering participated in 5 bidding packages and won all 5, all belonging to Vietnam Coal and Mineral Industry Group. Among them, Ha Lam Coal Joint Stock Company – Vinacomin has 3 bidding packages, the remaining Nui Beo Coal Joint Stock Company and Ha Long Coal Company – KTV, each company has 1 bidding package. The total value of 5 bidding packages is more than 41 billion VND.

Most of these bidding packages have only one contractor participating, Quang Ninh Joint Stock Company. Not to mention, the winning bid price of this business is only a few million to a few tens of million VND/bid package. There are packages that are equal to the exact price offered by the bidding party. That’s the bidding package “Rent a drilling machine for production” of Nui Beo Coal Joint Stock Company, with 13,897,885,834 VND.

2018, Quang Ninh Electrical Engineering participated in 6 bidding packages, winning all 6 packages, specifically, Lam Dong Aluminum Company Limited – KTV (2 bidding packages), Ha Lam Coal Joint Stock Company. – Vinacomin (3 bidding packages) and Ha Long Coal Company – KTV (1 bidding package). The total value that Quang Ninh Electrical Engineering won was more than 321 billion VND.

Among them, the most notable is: “Package No. 27: Supply of main vertical wells, secondary vertical wells; pipeline system, technical cables in 2 wells” of Ha Long Coal Company – KTV. This bidding package costs up to 266,106,352,000 VND.

The joint venture of VVMI Mechanical and Pressure Equipment Joint Stock Company and Quang Ninh Mechanical and Electrical Joint Stock Company won the bid with a price of 268,483,636,215 VND.

2017Quang Ninh Electrical Engineering participated in 2 bidding packages of the branch of Vietnam Coal and Mineral Industry Group – Ha Long Coal Company – TKV and won both.

First is “Package XL03: Construction and upgrade of camera system in Ha Rang and Tan Lap areas”with the winning bid price of 1,100,801,256 VND.

Second package tender package “HL03: Supply and installation of surveillance camera technology system in the furnace”. One confusing thing is that it is not clear how Quang Ninh Electrical Engineering was able to win the bid for 1,685,718,935 VND, a difference of exactly 1,148 VND compared to the package price (1,685,720,083 VND).

The continuous winning of bids, along with the move of “going it alone”, the winning price being close to the bid price,… has caused many people to question the relationship between the Coal and Mineral Industry Group. Vietnamese products with Quang Ninh Mechanical and Electrical Joint Stock Company.