Investigate the case of Trang Nemo and his staff causing trouble and hitting people

On the afternoon of November 22, after many days of deliberation, the People’s Court of District 1 (HCMC) did not pronounce the sentence as planned and returned the additional investigation file for the public disorder case against defendant Nguyen Xuan Huong Trang (also called Trang Nemo, owner of Trang Nemo shop) and four accomplices.

Previously, the Procuracy proposed the jury to punish defendant Trang for 6-12 months in prison for the crime of disturbing public order. The four defendants Pham Quyen Quy, Nguyen Ngoc Khuong, Nguyen Phuoc Tuan and Phan Hoang Nam were recommended at least 6 months in prison, and the maximum was 18 months in prison.

The jury again asked the person involved, Ms. Pham Le Khanh, about the issue of requesting criminal handling of Trang and his accomplices for causing injury. She still maintained this request, so the jury asked the defendants how to beat Ms. Khanh, except Trang Nemo.

According to Trang’s lawyer, before the jury entered the conference room, his client did not hit but only snatched the mask…

After conferring, the presiding judge of the hearing shall notify the return of the additional investigation file to clarify a number of new circumstances arising at the court.

Specifically, the issue of causing injury to Ms. Khanh and the request for criminal handling of this person involved. According to the court, it is necessary to clarify the act of causing injury inside and outside the store to avoid the crime.

The profile shows that due to a conflict with Tran Nguyen Tra My in online sales, Trang made an appointment to meet My at Trang Nemo store, Nguyen Cu Trinh ward, district 1. On the afternoon of January 16, My and Pham Le Khanh, Tran Thi Hoang Yen went to Trang’s store to “talk”.

Here, My and Yen entered the store to meet Trang apologizing, Khanh stood outside. At about 15 o’clock, when My was apologizing, Khanh entered the store and said that My was leaving, so there was an argument with Trang. At this time, Trang used her hand to pull Khanh’s mask, Khanh had inappropriate words. Hearing that, Quy and Trang rushed to grab her hair and hit Khanh. When Yen intervened, she was beaten by Khuong. Next, Nam and Tuan also participated in fighting Khanh.

At this time, a number of police officers came to the store and invited the relevant people to the office to work. When going out, Khanh said to Trang Nemo: “You don’t know who you bump into, you go out and watch me”. Seeing that, Trang Nemo used his hand to snatch Khanh’s mask and throw it on the street; Quy, Khuong, Nam, Tuan also rushed to beat Khanh. The incident caused insecurity and order in a section of the road in front of Trang Nemo store. Then, Khanh and Yen filed a criminal complaint against those who caused their injuries.

According to the conclusion of the assessment, Khanh suffered 3% injuries, and Yen did not have enough grounds to determine that there was an injury. After the incident, the People’s Committee of Nguyen Cu Trinh ward sent an official dispatch saying that the above fighting incident had adversely affected the security and order situation in the locality. At the same time, when the incident happened, many people gathered, used their phones to record and post it on social networks, information about the incident spread very quickly, causing people to have bad public opinion, affecting the public. to the situation of security, order and social safety in the locality. The Ward People’s Committee proposed to strictly handle the subjects in accordance with the law.

CANARY